Well, Dave the answer depends on several factors. First ask yourself which “type” of exercise are you doing? Secondly, WHY are you doing the movement. And don’t forget to ask, with what exercise device is the movement in question being preformed.

As to the “type” of movement. Is the exercise a compound or “multi joint” movement, or an isolation or “single joint” movement? Now, take that confused look of your face and let me explain.

A compound movement would be, say an overhead press. While an isolation movement would be a dumbbell lateral raise. Both movements involve the muscular makeup of the shoulder gird but one rotates around and involves “more” that a single joint, while the single joint movement “duh” would rotate and involve only ONE joints involvement. In a press, as you move into the TOP of the press less and less muscular involvement is present until at the very end of the movement (lock out) it is the bone structure that is supporting the weight, not the contractile strength of the muscles. On or during such a movement a pause or squeeze is of little value, a bit difficult to really squeeze the bone structure wouldn’t you agree? In compound movements it is of much greater value if you move slowly into a position of “almost” lockout then smoothly without pause return to a stretched position.

With the lateral raise you are performing a single joint or isolation movement that will result in the contraction of the lateral head of the deltoid when the weight reaches a position where the upper arm structure is parallel to the floor. HERE you should pause and let the muscle structure work to hold the weight in that position. This being done because it IS the muscle you are working that is actually holding the weight in that position.

Remember. foremost importance in any exercise is the amount of muscular involvement in the movement. While it is impossible to involve ALL the available muscle fibers in a contraction, one must strive to involve as may fibers as he or she can, and when this is accomplished ( at the position of full contraction.. The ONLY position that involves the maximum amount of fiber involvement) the most in results will be generated if a small “hold” or squeeze is executed through muscular contraction, insuring that as many fibers as humanly possible are stimulated to experience the resulting growth stimulus. All going back to the total amount of time a muscle is under the load of the weight during exercise.

Now ask yourself “why” you are doing the movement. Is it to “look” good to the girl on the stair stepper or your buddies in the gym, or is it to get the MOST out of what time you spend in the training process. If the answer is the later, then pause when the muscle you are trying to work is actually doing the max amount of work, thus creating the most in results.

 

And finally ask with what training tool are you performing the movement. Not all machines actually offer resistance of a significant nature in the final fully contracted position, while others do. Always migrate to the machine that offers this feature, oh and it will be the one that you DON”T appear to be the son of Hercules when you use it. And if say dumbbells are used for the lateral raises, then ONLY if the trainee stops the upward movement at a position where the upper arm is parallel to the floor will the proper resistance be applied at the point of full contraction of the lateral deltoid head.

2 Responses to “”

  1. davebok Says:

    Hi Doc,
    Let me introduce myself—(this isn’t Dave) it’s Gina. Thanks for the answer to the above question. I had someone ask me this the other day and I know I didn’t give as great an explanation as you did.

    I want to know what you think of PowerBars (this particular brand) Do they enhance sports/weightlifting performance? Are they necessary or can you get all the carbs for energy you need through diet? (I know they are convenient in our fast food cutlture!)

    I also want to know what you think about whey protein. Who should use it, how much and when. What is it good for? Do you think it is safe to use?

    Thanks,
    Gina Bokmiller

  2. benchmark2545 Says:

    HI Gina,

    Let’s see if I can shed some light on your questions without sounding condescending in any way.

    Many of the questions I have fielded from day to day over the past 5 decades seem to revolve around the nutrition or more like it “super nutrition” that many athletes and trainees seek and believe in with little regard to the actual facts that are readily available to all. And it matters little if the person standing in front of me is an athlete, a bodybuilder, or simply someone who is working to reinvent themselves in a more healthy context. All seem to have one thing in common, the belief or hope that there is some “secret’ food or foods that will be a crucial aid in their quest, all seeming to be assured that such a product will speed up their results and make their ultimate end come about in a more dramatic fashion.

    I would dare say that most that use the “power bars” are in the same boat. Oh and if you pay real close attention, that boats got more holes in it than my Uncle Frank’s old socks. As to your specific question DO THEY (POWER BARS) ENHANCE SPORTS/WEIGHTLIFTING PERFORMANCE? aRE THEY NECESSARY?

    The products sold on the vast health/sports market… are for the most part no more effective than many other less expensive food sources that would offer the same thing … a qucik carb fix.

    Now you can spend a small fortune on these prewrapped bundles of energy, all the while believing they offer some magical ingredent (which they DO NOT) or you could simply consume a banana, or a couple spoon fulls of peanut butter, or even a few handfulls of raisins, and get the exact same thing. They are only as “necessary” as the particular trainee believes them to be. That’s the whole premise behind the millions
    of dollars in advertising spend each year on such products, to make more and more “believe”.

    Let me give you a simple example of this:
    Some years ago, I was training a very remarkable young man. He was tremendously strong, and was a joy to work with, in that he responded so quickly to proper training, plus with his genetic background, such gains were fast and furious in their appearacne.

    He had come to believe that inorder to have a great workout, that when driving to the gym, and the same stop sign each day, he would place under his tongue one single green jelly bean. Now anyone with half a brain would easily see that this was simply a personal habit that had little on no value, but this young man believed it with a passion, and since he was making so much progress so quickly it was only a matter of time that others at the gym that came in contact with him during his training were following the same absurd practice. That ONE jelly bean didn’t have near the calories that your Power Bar has, but it fuelled this man’s training to the very zenith of performance. Why? He belived it did, so it did.

    Are Power Bars magic? ONLY if you see them as such. There are so many other ways to get the needed carbs in ones diet without eating something that is by it’s own labeling 76% sugar.

    And as far as whey protein goes, pretty much the same thing. If you believe “they will come” as the fella said when he built a baseball field in the middle of his corn crop. Then THEY will come! There is NO magic protein. There is NO magic food period. It is a case of personal preference.

    And in passing remember, very little is needed in the diet in the way of protein. It is only the people that are selling it to you that want you to believe anything else. Protein needs are based solely on the lean bodyweight of an individual. While the food supplement industry would have us believe that it is the KEY element in muscle growth, it isn’t that key element is the intensity of training that triggers the growth process. Once triggered, it will take place, even in the absence of protein intake.Is it important? YES as any essential nutrient is. Is it a MAGIC key to success? OH my I wish it was, but it isn’t.

    And remember, they call them food supplements … they ARE NOT FOOD. We should all get our nutrients from food sources when ever we can, not powers and pills.

    Are they (whey proteins) safe? Well, don’t forget that protein has an established caloric value, too much and you end up making “gains” that few would like. Too many calories equals fat, plain and simple.

    Does whey protein produce more in the way of muscle gains than other protein sources, there is NO credible evidence that it builds muscle faster or in any manner different than any other protein source. The only problem will be with some individuals that are hypersensitive to milk.

    Hope this helps,
    Doc

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.